Drop 'Em Like They're Hot, Part 1
All this semester, D2U has sponsored a Faculty Book Study group to read and discuss Ken Bain's What the Best College Teachers Do. Our group seems to be made up of most of the more dedicated professors and instructors on campus; I'm one of the few part-timers in the bunch. The discussions have been very enlightening, as all of us want to make our teaching as effective and creative as possible. But one science professor spoke up in yesterday's meeting with a well-placed criticism of Bain's book, and spelled out part of my teaching philosophy.
"I simply can't be all things to all students," Dr. B* said. "Bain makes it sound as if it's our job to motivate students, but we all know that they have to meet us halfway. Chances are that I can't make someone excited about learning biology at D2U if they don't want to be here. And for those students who don't want to learn...well, I'll cut them loose and focus on reaching the ones who do."
Amen, sister!
Students have to put in as much effort as I do. Otherwise, they're wasting both my time and theirs, and they're taking up a seat in my class that could've gone to someone who really needed the class this particular semester. One such student was in my 11:00 Comp II class...but is no longer. Heh-heh.
Rihanna* was in my Comp I class this past Fall Semester. She's an average student; if she put forth a little more effort, she could write fairly well. Her first paper in my class earned a B-, but she slacked off after that and ended up with a solid C in Comp I. I was surprised to see her sign up for my Comp II.
Rihanna had really slacked off in Comp II, though, and was on track to make a D, if she got lucky. Most days, she couldn't be bothered to pay attention, do the reading, or ask questions in class. She seemed to me to have severe Spring Fever, or maybe a case of the I-don't-give-a-shits. I was very disappointed.
On all my syllabi, in all my classes and at all my schools, I spell out my absence policies very clearly. I will count students absent if they sleep in class, send text messages on cell phones, read other materials than our book, talk with classmates, or otherwise not participate in the class discussion. I make notes in the roll book whenever I notice a student doing these things, and these "in-class absences" count against the four allotted absences they get in my class.
Rihanna* had already been out of class on two separate occasions when I noticed her text-messaging furiously a couple weeks ago. So I noted her in-class absence. The next class period, she was reading her history book all class long—for 75 minutes, she looked in the other book and did not raise her eyes to even look at the other class members. (I walk through the aisles as the discussion goes on, and check to see what students are doing as we talk about the readings.) Then, for the third class day in a row, Rihanna chose not to participate; she doodled on a piece of notebook paper all class long. I noted her third in-class absence and the reason for it, and tallied up her absences.
Five. An automatic WF ("withdrawn/failing").
I dropped Rihanna from the class Tuesday afternoon. Wednesday morning, I got this e-mail, just as it appears here:
I recieved a email today saying that I have been dropped from your class for excessive absences. I know for a fact that I have only missed your class two times. Last thursday and another time in early february. Ive never been late or anything. I do not understand why I have been dropped from your class. I would really appreciate it if you could explain to me why. Thank you
How could she not know why I'd dropped her? Oh, wait—she must have forgotten what I stated in the syllabus. So I replied, and included the appropriate portion of the class syllabus:
Hi, Rihanna...
If you will recall from page 2 of our syllabus:
- This class will begin on time every class day, and I will take roll at the beginning of every class.
- You must arrive on time in order to be counted as present.
- You will be counted as absent if you leave class early.
- You will be given ½ an absence if you arrive late.
- You will be counted absent if you sleep in class.
- You will be counted absent if you’re talking with your classmates about topics unrelated to class discussion…
- Or sending IMs…
- Or writing notes back and forth to your classmates…
- Or checking your cell phone to see if anyone has called.
- If you’re not here, awake, with your book, and paying attention, you’re absent.
- Four absences = drop from class with WF.
Please note the next-to-last line in particular: "If you're not here, awake, with your book, and paying attention, you're absent."
As I have stated in the syllabus, you MUST be paying attention with your book open to be counted as present, and you were doing *neither* of those things in three separate class meetings. In these three class meetings, I have observed you either sending text messages on your phone (March 20), reading a book other than our Comp II text (March 22--I seem to remember seeing a history book in front of you as I walked by--your English book not in front of you), and doodling *all class long* on a piece of paper (March 27--with your book nowhere in sight). I counted you as absent those days, with a special notation of the "in-class absence." With your additional two absences when you were not physically in class, they added up to five absences. Therefore, I dropped you from Comp II.
I encourage you to take Comp II at another time, when you feel more prepared to give your full time, attention, and participation to the course.
Thankfully, I've gotten no angry e-mails from her Mama, nor has my department head gotten any angry phone calls. But I wouldn't be surprised if that happens.
Two or three more in that 11:00 class will probably be dropped next week for similar reasons—chronic latecomers are about to "taste the sweaty, bewhiskered 'Taint of Truth," as CrankyProf would say. That group has been a real disappointment, and they're just going to have to learn the hard way that every action has a consequence.
Labels: Students on Ice, Teaching

























