It’s that time of the semester: when almost all composition classes begin discussing the oft-dreaded first essay. This term, I’m doing something different, something very unsettling to a classroom control freak like me: letting my students choose their own essay topics, as long as those topics are somewhat related to our readings.
For many years, I went to a huge amount of trouble every few weeks to write up/beg/borrow/steal essay topics for my students. The bad thing was that the students rarely, if ever, responded very well to the essay questions (see Student Essay Insanity #5 for an example). D2U’s new Director of First-Year Composition, Dr. Rhettencomp*, had a suggestion: “Why don’t you let them come up with their own topics? It’d be a lot less work on you, and it’d force them to flex their intellectual muscles.”
“Do
what?!?”
“Let them come up with their own topics. It works really well in my classes,” Dr. Rhettencomp replied.
“You mean...you...let them choose what they’re going to write on?” This was heavy material for me to consider. “But I don’t trust my students to come up with write-able, decent topics.”
He understood my hesitance. “I used to be the same way. But I realized that students
need to learn how to figure out the most important things to write about—the most important lessons to take out of the readings. Think about it: in the ‘real world,’ nobody’s going to hand them a list of topics and say, ‘Write.’” He paused for another sip of coffee. “For the last six or seven minutes of every class, I ask the students to write in their notebooks about the most interesting idea, concept, or issue that we talked about that day. If they do that for, say, two or three weeks’ worth of classes, there is
no fucking way they’ll be without material for essay topics of their own.”
I laughed at his inclusion of the “no fucking way.” And I also laughed at my own reticence to trust my students. This would save me
hours of worry and trouble, and it’d make my students think and reconsider the material. It would
force them to talk with me before and after class about potential topics, about introductions and conclusions, about how to say what they mean and mean what they say. It might even force them to make trips to see me during office hours. Or trips to the D2U Writing Center.
Damn. My Comp classes were movin’ on up like George and Weezy Jefferson. Fish don't fry in the kitchen, y'all.
In class today, I introduced this new concept. My morning Intro to Lit students were wary of choosing their own topics for their poetry papers, having never been given this sort of freedom in an academic setting. While they were mostly enthusiastic, a few whined a little. I told them to suck it up and pick a damn poem (but not in those exact words). My afternoon Comp I students were even more wary of this choose-your-own-topic stuff. Okay, maybe
wary isn't quite the right word. A few of them simply stunned me with their complete apathy. “Can’t you just
assign us a topic?” one asked. “I mean, like, I really can’t think of anything to write on. Like, I’m just...you know...
blah.” Ah, I love the inarticulate ones best of all.
“I can,” I replied, “but I can also guarantee that you’ll absolutely
hate it.”
“No, really, Professor Kitty,” the student continued. “Just assign me one.”
“All right.” I took a deep breath. “Your paper will be on
The Scarlet Letter and—"
“Okay!
Okay! I’ll think up my own!”
Labels: Teaching, Writing